HomeShoppingMaytag MET8720DS review: Two ovens for the price of one

Maytag MET8720DS review: Two ovens for the price of one

Published on

The $1,600 Maytag Gemini MET8720DS could supply two ovens for the worth of 1, nevertheless it does not match into any of those classes. It suffers from inconsistent efficiency, few superior options, an unresponsive show panel with no quantity pad, and a mishmash of stainless-steel and cheap-looking plasticky accent items.

It is not precisely a dangerous vary, however you could find one thing higher for roughly the identical value.

Set your sights on the Maytag Gemini double-oven vary (photos)

See all photos

This is the factor

Maytag’s Gemini MET8720DS appears like a price range vary with a number of well-placed slabs of stainless-steel thrown into the combination to function a distraction. We have seen elegantly-appointed midpriced fashions, just like the $1,700 Samsung NX58F5700 and even standout entry-level choices, like GE’s $600 retro-inspired Artistry range .

That is to not say that the Gemini utterly misses the mark, nevertheless it’s an odd hybrid of nice-looking, stainless-steel-wrapped double ovens with low-cost plastic-looking painted steel handles and burner knobs.

Tyler Lizenby/CNET

And you’ll neglect about additional options. To your $1,600, you get a 2.5-cubic-foot prime oven and a 4.2-cubic-foot backside oven — that is it. There isn’t any broiler pan accent or particular sliding oven rack. It is all very fundamental, together with the show panel, which deserted the thought of a quantity pad for setting instances and temperatures in favor of space-saving plus and minus buttons.

That would not be so dangerous if the contact pad have been extra responsive, nevertheless it’s fairly cussed. I would not go so far as saying that you will threat a really minor finger damage attempting to press down every button, nevertheless it positively takes extra effort than I’d have anticipated.

Attending to the great things


Tyler Lizenby/CNET

For the reason that double oven is the principle function of this vary, I made a decision to kick off testing with a frozen pizza within the smaller prime oven and a whole-roasted rooster within the bigger backside one. I will get to the rooster in a minute, however for now, let’s all simply take a second to understand the tacky goodness that is taking place within the image above.

You actually cannot go incorrect with pizza. It is such a staple of the American weight-reduction plan that it will be irresponsible to not embrace it on this spherical of testing. That is very true because the 2.5-cubic-foot higher oven is completely sized for a single rack — of something actually — however I instantly considered frozen pizza.

The directions say to preheat the over to 400 levels and to cook dinner it for 22 to 26 minutes. Happily, this oven dealt with the DiGiorno “Italian Fashion Favorites” pizza with out criticism, ending the pizza inside the allotted timeframe. It was a welcome and engaging introduction to the Maytag Gemini.


Tyler Lizenby/CNET

Whereas the higher oven was busy baking a pizza, the decrease one was concurrently roasting a rooster. It turned out fairly nicely. That is the principle benefit of this vary over any single-oven mannequin we have examined to this point — it affords up far more multitasking potential. I opted for 2 “foremost programs” with the pizza and the rooster, however you might simply as simply cook dinner a aspect dish up prime and an entree under or an entree on prime oven and a few racks of cookies beneath. What’s higher than tasty meals? Tasty meals that you could cook dinner rapidly and effectively.

Along with the simultaneous meals checks, I additionally calculated how lengthy the higher and decrease ovens every took to succeed in 350 levels in conventional bake mode. As you’ll count on, the higher oven reached 350 levels in much less time — 11 minutes and 51 seconds — whereas the decrease oven took 13 minutes and 33 seconds. This is not an enormous distinction, however there is a particular time and power profit to sticking with the highest oven for single-rack cooking.


Tyler Lizenby/CNET

After the pizza and rooster, I moved on to burger-broiling and biscuit-baking; I used the bigger decrease oven for these checks.

For broiling, I organized six 5.3-ounce burgers on a pan and caught a temperature probe in every. Then, I tracked how lengthy it took for every burger to succeed in a medium-rare/medium 145 levels. In comparison with different electrical ovens we have examined, the Maytag Gemini did simply OK.

Hamburger broiling check

LG LRE3021ST 14.75Samsung NE58H9970WS 14.9Maytag MET8720DS 15.58GE ABS45DFBS 15.67GE JB650SFSS 16.25

Observe: Time to attain 145 levels F, in minutes

It took quarter-hour and 35 seconds for all the burgers to hit the goal temperature, which is healthier than GE’s $800 JB650SFSS and $600 ABS45DFBS , however worse than the $3,600 Samsung NE58H9970WS and the $800 LG LRE3021ST .



I additionally baked a great deal of biscuits within the Gemini. Wanting on the collage above, you may see the normal double-rack prime and backside rack biscuits on the highest row and the convection double rack prime and backside rack biscuits on the underside row.

The double-rack biscuits on the highest row have that telltale conventional bake mode colour disparity. You possibly can clearly see that the highest rack is far more “performed” than the underside rack. That can be true for the convection double rack biscuits; the convection fan did subsequent to nothing to enhance total baking evenness.

Giant burner boil check

Samsung NE58H9970WS 7.40Electrolux EI30EF35JS 9.62Maytag MET8720DS 9.7KitchenAid KERS303BSS0 10.48Whirlpool WFE720H0AS0 10.98LG LRE3027ST 12.17Samsung NE58F9710WS 14.53

Observe: Time to attain rolling boil, in minutes

The big burner boil check measures how lengthy it takes for a 5-quart pot filled with water to succeed in a rolling boil. This check makes use of probably the most highly effective burner on the cooktop, which is probably going the burner you’d flip to for cooking pasta.

The Gemini did notably nicely right here, ending the duty in simply 9 minutes and 42 seconds. Samsung’s $3,700 induction NE58H9970WS took the shortest period of time (lower than 8 minutes) and its $2,300 electrical NE58F9710WS took the longest period of time (over 14 minutes).

Small burner boil check

Samsung NE58H9970WS 5.72Whirlpool WFE720H0AS0 10.22KitchenAid KERS303BSS0 10.67Samsung NE58F9710WS 11.88Electrolux EI30EF35JS 13.37Maytag MET8720DS 13.52LG LRE3027ST 15.10

Observe: Time to attain rolling boil, in minutes

In stark distinction to its stable giant burner boil outcomes, Maytag’s MET8720DS didn’t carry out very nicely on the small burner. It took a median of 13 minutes and 31 seconds to succeed in a rolling boil. That may be thought-about fairly darn good if we have been speaking a couple of gasoline cooktop, however the electrical fashions have a tendency to succeed in the boiling level sooner. Solely the $1,400 LG LRE3027ST scored worse than the Gemini at over quarter-hour; the $3,699 Samsung NE58H9970WS scored the most effective at lower than 6 minutes.

In conclusion

Maytag’s $1,599 MET8720DS can boil, bake, roast and broil, however its underwhelming design, number-pad-less show panel, restricted options and variable efficiency outcomes make it a mediocre selection at finest. For those who’re on the hunt for a fundamental double-oven electrical vary, the Gemini can get the job performed; simply do not count on to be overly impressed by the outcomes.

Nonetheless, you may wish to keep tuned for our upcoming assessment of the $1,900 Samsung NE59J7850WS Dual Door Flex Duo . For a number of hundred {dollars} extra, it affords the added versatility of a detachable divider that simply converts the massive single oven cavity into two separate oven compartments.


Latest articles

More like this